Hush money

We provide a simple incomplete-information model wherein an initially uninformed plaintiff makes a menu of settlement demands (one of which involves confidentiality) of the informed defendant. The defendant is informed about both his culpability in the harm suffered by the current plaintiff and the existence of other plaintiffs. The possibility that there are other plaintiffs the defendant might face improves the current plaintiffs bargaining position, as the likelihood of follow-on suits depends upon the visibility of the outcome of the current case. For this reason, the defendant may be willing to pay "hush money.".