How do stroke units improve patient outcomes? A collaborative systematic review of the randomized trials

被引:250
作者
Asplund, K
Berman, P
Blomstrand, C
Dennis, M
Erila, T
Garraway, M
Hamrin, E
Hankey, G
Ilmavirta, M
Indredavik, B
Kalra, L
Kaste, M
Langhorne, P
Rodgers, H
Sivenius, J
Slattery, J
Stevens, R
Svensson, A
Warlow, C
Williams, B
WoodDauphinee, S
Deleo, D
Drummond, A
Fogelholm, R
Lincoln, N
Palomaki, H
Strand, T
Wilhelmsen, L
Counsell, C
Fraser, H
机构
[1] UMEA UNIV HOSP, S-90185 UMEA, SWEDEN
[2] CITY HOSP, NOTTINGHAM NG5 1PB, ENGLAND
[3] SAHLGRENS UNIV HOSP, S-41345 GOTHENBURG, SWEDEN
[4] WESTERN GEN HOSP, EDINBURGH EH4 2XU, MIDLOTHIAN, SCOTLAND
[5] TAMPERE UNIV HOSP, TAMPERE, FINLAND
[6] UNIV EDINBURGH, EDINBURGH EH8 9YL, MIDLOTHIAN, SCOTLAND
[7] LINKOPING UNIV, LINKOPING, SWEDEN
[8] ROYAL PERTH HOSP, PERTH, WA, AUSTRALIA
[9] CENT HOSP JYVASKYLA, JYVASKYLA, FINLAND
[10] UNIV HOSP, TRONDHEIM, NORWAY
[11] UNIV HELSINKI, HELSINKI, FINLAND
[12] ROYAL INFIRM, GLASGOW G31 2ER, LANARK, SCOTLAND
[13] UNIV NEWCASTLE, NEWCASTLE, ENGLAND
[14] UNIV KUOPIO, FIN-70211 KUOPIO, FINLAND
[15] UNIV EDINBURGH, EDINBURGH, MIDLOTHIAN, SCOTLAND
[16] OSTRA HOSP, S-41685 GOTHENBURG, SWEDEN
[17] WESTERN GEN HOSP, EDINBURGH EH4 2XU, MIDLOTHIAN, SCOTLAND
[18] GARTNAVEL ROYAL HOSP, GLASGOW, LANARK, SCOTLAND
[19] MCGILL UNIV, MONTREAL, PQ, CANADA
关键词
meta-analysis; outcome; rehabilitation; stroke management; stroke units;
D O I
10.1161/01.STR.28.11.2139
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background and Purpose We sought to clarify the way in which organized inpatient (stroke unit) care can produce reductions in case fatality and in the need for institutional care after stroke. Methods We performed a secondary analysis of a collaborative systematic review of all randomized trials that compared organized inpatient (stroke unit) care with contemporary conventional care. Nineteen trials were included, of which 18 (3246 patients) could provide outcome data on death, place of residence, and final functional outcome. Data were less complete (but always available for at least 12 trials; 1611 patients) for subgroup analyses examining timing and cause of death and outcomes in patients with different levels of severity of initial stroke. Results The reduction in case fatality of patients managed in a stroke unit setting developed between 1 and 4 weeks after the index stroke. The reduction in the odds of death was evident across all causes of death and most marked for those deaths considered to be secondary to immobility. However, data were insufficient to permit a firm conclusion. The relative increase in the number of patients discharged home from stroke units as opposed to conventional care was largely attributable to an increase in the number of patients returning home physically independent. Across the range of stroke severity, stroke unit care was associated with nonsignificant increases in the number of patients regaining independence. Conclusions Within the limitations of the available data, we conclude that organized inpatient stroke unit care probably benefits a wide range of stroke patients in a variety of different ways, ie, reducing death from secondary complications of stroke and reducing the need for institutional care through a reduction in disability.
引用
收藏
页码:2139 / 2144
页数:6
相关论文
共 30 条
[1]  
Aitken PD, 1993, AGE AGEING S2, V22, P4
[2]  
Asplund K, 1997, BMJ-BRIT MED J, V314, P1151
[3]   CLASSIFICATION AND NATURAL-HISTORY OF CLINICALLY IDENTIFIABLE SUBTYPES OF CEREBRAL INFARCTION [J].
BAMFORD, J ;
SANDERCOCK, P ;
DENNIS, M ;
BURN, J ;
WARLOW, C .
LANCET, 1991, 337 (8756) :1521-1526
[4]   FORTNIGHTLY REVIEW - SO STROKE UNITS SAVE LIVES - WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE [J].
DENNIS, M ;
LANGHORNE, P .
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 309 (6964) :1273-1277
[5]   METAANALYSIS IN CLINICAL-TRIALS [J].
DERSIMONIAN, R ;
LAIRD, N .
CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIALS, 1986, 7 (03) :177-188
[6]  
EBRAHIM S, 1990, CLIN EPIDEMIOLOGY ST
[7]  
FAGERBERG B, 1993, LANCET, V342, P992
[8]   A COMPARISON OF FUNCTIONALLY ORIENTATED MEDICAL CARE AND FORMAL REHABILITATION IN MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH HEMIPLEGIA DUE TO CEREBROVASCULAR DISEASE [J].
FELDMAN, DJ ;
LLOYD, K ;
RUSK, HA ;
LEE, PR ;
UNTERECK.J ;
TOOLE, A .
JOURNAL OF CHRONIC DISEASES, 1962, 15 (MAR) :297-&
[9]   STROKE REHABILITATION UNITS - CONCEPTS, EVALUATION, AND UNRESOLVED ISSUES [J].
GARRAWAY, M .
STROKE, 1985, 16 (02) :178-181
[10]   MANAGEMENT OF ACUTE STROKE IN THE ELDERLY - FOLLOW-UP OF A CONTROLLED TRIAL [J].
GARRAWAY, WM ;
AKHTAR, AJ ;
HOCKEY, L ;
PRESCOTT, RJ .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1980, 281 (6244) :827-829