Prospective Evaluation of an Extended 21-Core Biopsy Scheme as Initial Prostate Cancer Diagnostic Strategy

Background: The debate on the optimal number of prostate biopsy core samples that should be taken as an initial strategy is open. Objective: To prospectively evaluate the diagnostic yield of a 21-core biopsy protocol as an initial strategy for prostate cancer (PCa) detection. Design, setting, and participants: During 10 yr, 2753 consecutive patients underwent a 21-core biopsy scheme for their first set of biopsy specimens. Intervention: All patients underwent a standardized 21-core protocol with cores mapped for location. Outcome measurements and statistical analysis: The PCa detection rate of each biopsy scheme (6, 12, or 21 cores) was compared using a McNemar test. Predictive factors of the diagnostic yield achieved by a 21-core scheme were studied using logistic regression analyses. Results and limitations: PCa detection rates using 6 sextant biopsies, 12 cores, and 21 cores were 32.5%, 40.4%, and 43.3%, respectively. The 12-core procedure improved the cancer detection rate by 19.4% (p = 0.004), and the 21-biopsy scheme improved the rate by 6.7% overall (p < 0.001). The six far lateral cores were the most efficient in terms of detection rate. The diagnostic yield of the 21-core protocol was > 10% in prostates with volume > 70 ml, in men with a prostate-specific antigen level < 4 ng/ml, with a prostate-specific antigen density (PSAD) < 0.20 ng/ml per gram. A PSAD < 0.20 ng/ml per gram was the strongest independent predictive factor of the diagnostic yield offered by the 21-core scheme (p < 0.001). The 21-core protocol significantly increased the rate of PCa eligible for active surveillance (62.5% vs 48.4%; p = 0.036) than those detected by a 12-core scheme without statistically increasing the rate of insignificant PCa (p = 0.503). Conclusions: A 21-core biopsy scheme improves significantly the PCa detection rate compared with a 12-core protocol. We identified a cut-off PSAD (0.20 ng/ml per gram) below which an extended 21-core scheme might be systematically proposed to significantly improve the overall detection rate without increasing the rate of detected insignificant PCa. (C) 2012 European Association of Urology. Published by Elsevier B. V. All rights reserved.