5 ATTEMPTS TO REPLICATE EXPERIMENTER BIAS EFFECT

被引:45
作者
BARBER, TX
FORGIONE, A
CHAVES, JF
CALVERLE.DS
MCPEAKE, JD
BOWEN, B
机构
[1] Medfield State Hosp., Mass
关键词
E bias effect; replication of R. Rosenthal &; K. Fode's study;
D O I
10.1037/h0027229
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
5 investigations, involving 501 undergraduate Ss and 51 undergraduate Es were conducted to cross-validate a study by R. Rosenthal and K. Fode (see 38:3) which demonstrated the E bias effect (EBE). Each of the 5 studies failed to demonstrate that Es' expectancy-biases influence their results (overall F < 1). The 5 studies are related to other studies in this area, the majority of which also failed to demonstrate the EBE. It is concluded that the effect is more difficult to demonstrate than was implied in several recent reviews and that it is not known now what preconditions are necessary to obtain it. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2006 APA, all rights reserved). © 1969 American Psychological Association.
引用
收藏
页码:1 / &
相关论文
共 15 条
[1]   FACT FICTION AND EXPERIMENTER BIAS EFFECT [J].
BARBER, TX ;
SILVER, MJ .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1968, 70 (6P2) :1-&
[2]   PITFALLS IN DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION - A REPLY TO ROSENTHAL [J].
BARBER, TX ;
SILVER, MJ .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1968, 70 (6P2) :48-&
[3]  
BORGATTA EF, 1967, HANDBOOK PERSONAL ED
[4]  
KLINTZ BL, 1965, PSYCHOLOGICAL B, V63, P223
[5]  
LASZLO JP, 1967, SUBJECT DOGMATISM EX
[6]  
MAHER BA, 1964, PROGRESS EXPERIME ED, V1
[7]  
MCGUIRE WJ, 1967, HANDBOOK PERSONALITY
[8]   COVERT COMMUNICATION IN PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPERIMENT [J].
ROSENTHAL, R .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1967, 67 (05) :356-+
[9]   PSYCHOLOGY OF THE SCIENTIST .5. 3 EXPERIMENTS IN EXPERIMENTER BIAS [J].
ROSENTHAL, R ;
FODE, KL .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORTS, 1963, 12 (02) :491-511
[10]  
ROSENTHAL R, 1963, AM SCI, V51, P268